Phoebe Bridgers, Ryan Adams, and the Songs That Keep Emotional Receipts
Written In Reverb: Annette Geneva steps into Phoebe Bridgers’ Stranger in the Alps, a haunted little map of grief, sex, power, loneliness, friendship and memory; an album where desire comes tangled with discomfort, the ghosts in your phone refuse to stay quiet, and the songs don’t just break your heart so much as keep the receipts.
THE RYAN ADAMS PROBLEM
I am a big Phoebe Bridgers fan and supporter, but this album feels different to me than anything else she ever released. It’s a little like that saying … “take it with a grain of salt". And here’s why.
I have a complicated relationship with Ryan Adams. And by complicated, I don’t mean that in the vague internet sense of I used to like him but then I read some things. I talked to him. There were conversations. Real conversations, not the parasocial kind where you send a musician a message and stare at the little “seen” notification while pretending you don’t care whether they answer. We talked over several years. Basically every time he’d do an Australian tour - we’d talk.
And that changes the way I hear Stranger in the Alps. Because Ryan Adams isn’t some abstract character in Phoebe Bridgers’ history to me.
He’s a person whose voice I knew from records and whose actual voice I knew from conversations. That is a very strange place to find yourself when you are also listening to a young woman write about her experience with that same person. It creates this uncomfortable little collision between music and reality.
The Ryan Adams I knew through his records was already enormous in my imagination. That was the man who had written all those songs. The person behind Heartbreaker, Gold, Love Is Hell. The guy musicians talked about. The guy whose work could make you feel as though someone had somehow crawled inside your head and rearranged your thoughts.
Then there was the actual person. The one who could send a message. The one I could have a conversation with. The one I could tell to go and reorganise his wardrobe that had ridiculous amount of graphic tees. And when someone you have listened to for years suddenly becomes an actual human being on your phone, the lore gets very weird, very quickly. You realise that the person who wrote the song isn’t the song. It sounds obvious.
But it isn’t when you’ve spent years loving someone’s work. I think that’s one of the reasons Stranger in the Alps has stayed with me. I don’t get to hear “Motion Sickness” as a distant piece of indie-rock gossip.
I hear it with an additional layer of knowledge. Phoebe knew him personally, intimately. I love her work, I loved his at one point. And those two things can exist at the same time.
That’s uncomfortable. But it’s also fascinating.
When I first heard “Motion Sickness”, I didn’t necessarily know exactly where it was going. Then you hear the lyrics.
And you realise. Oh. This is about Ryan. And suddenly the song has another dimension.
The genius is that Phoebe doesn’t make it sound like a courtroom statement. She makes it sound like a pop song. A really fucking good one. The melody is almost buoyant. The guitar has movement. There is this ridiculous brightness to it. And underneath it is a woman describing what it feels like to be emotionally destabilised by someone who had enormous power over her.
“I have emotional motion sickness.” It is one of those lines that is almost too perfect. And yet it doesn’t feel written to become a famous lyric. It feels like someone finally finding the exact words for a sensation they couldn’t previously articulate.
I’ve experienced enough relationships to understand that particular weirdness. Musicians can occupy a strange position in your life. They are simultaneously ordinary people and people whose work can have enormous emotional power over you. You can be talking to someone who has played in front of thousands of people and still be discussing something incredibly mundane. You can know the person who wrote the song and still be moved by the song as though you have never met them.
The two versions don’t cancel each other out. They sit beside each other.
And sometimes they fight.
There is also the “Motion Sickness” video. I love it because it refuses to behave like a revenge video. Phoebe isn’t standing in a rain-soaked bedroom staring through a window while somebody slowly pans around her face. She’s riding around Los Angeles. She’s in a tuxedo. She’s on a scooter. There is karaoke. There is this dreamy, slightly surreal quality to the whole thing. The song is about emotional nausea. The video is about movement. And I think that is exactly right. You don’t always heal by sitting still and understanding everything. Sometimes you heal by leaving. Sometimes you put on something ridiculous and get on a scooter. Sometimes you sing. Sometimes you make the thing that hurt you into something that makes other people dance. There is something incredibly powerful about that.
One of the strangest things about having actually spoken to Ryan is that I can’t pretend I have some clean, simple relationship to the story. I have memories of conversations with him. I have memories of the person I was when those conversations happened. I have the songs. And then I have everything that came later. The allegations. The stories. Phoebe speaking publicly about her experience.
The understanding of power and age and influence becoming impossible to ignore. And I think that is what happens when you get older. The things you once thought were simple become complicated. You learn that someone can be talented and still hurt people. Someone can make beautiful things and behave terribly.
Someone can be kind to you and still have done things that are indefensible to somebody else. Someone can be important to a period of your life without being someone you would choose to have in your life now. That’s an uncomfortable lesson. But it is an important one.
And I don’t think Stranger in the Alps asks us to solve it. Phoebe isn’t interested in making the listener comfortable. She’s interested in telling the truth of her own experience.
That’s enough.
There are musicians you admire. Musicians you fancy. Musicians you know. Musicians you think you know.
And then there are the musicians whose records become attached to particular versions of yourself.
That last category is the dangerous one. Because once a record becomes attached to your life, you can never completely separate it again.
You can hear three seconds of a song and suddenly you’re twenty-eight again. Or drunk. Or heartbroken. Or standing backstage. Or driving somewhere. Or talking to someone you haven’t spoken to in years. That is what music does. It keeps receipts.
This is one of the things I admire most about Phoebe. She doesn’t over-explain. She gives you fragments.
“Scott Street” is a perfect example.
The song was written with Marshall Vore, who was not simply a collaborator but someone with whom Phoebe had a personal history. Vore had the beginnings of the song, and together they developed it into something that became one of the defining tracks on Stranger in the Alps. Their songwriting relationship continued across several songs on the album. That personal history matters because “Scott Street” doesn’t sound like an exposition. It sounds like remembering someone. And those are very different things.
When I remember people I’ve known through music, I don’t remember their biographies. I remember fragments.
A conversation. A particular sentence.
A face in a particular room. A message.
A voice. A stupid joke. The way somebody looked at me. The way I felt afterwards. That’s how Phoebe writes.
She doesn’t hand you the complete file.
She gives you the photograph. You fill in the rest.
Phoebe’s songwriting process on this record was collaborative, messy and wonderfully unprecious. Marshall Vore was central to the album. Conor Oberst appears on “Would You Rather.” Which is one of my favourite songs on the record. The production team of Tony Berg and Ethan Gruska helped turn the songs into these strange little cinematic worlds.
And the record was built through experimentation rather than some magical songwriter sitting alone in a cabin waiting for divine inspiration.
I love hearing that.
Because when you spend time around musicians, you realise songwriting is often much less romantic than people imagine. It’s work. It’s collaboration.
It’s trying something stupid. It’s someone saying, “What if we do this?”
It’s somebody else saying, “No.” It’s playing the same section twelve times.
It’s keeping the weird take because something about it feels alive. Then eventually, somehow, you’ve got a record.
Stranger in the Alps sounds like it was recorded inside a memory. There are acoustic guitars, electric guitars, pedal steel, strings and subtle electronic textures.
Everything feels close. Nothing is screaming for your attention. The arrangements are beautiful without being ornamental. Tony Berg and Ethan Gruska understood that the songs didn’t need to be buried underneath production. They needed atmosphere. Space. Air.
Phoebe’s voice sits inside that space almost conversationally.
And then something enormous happens around her. A harmony. A string arrangement. A sudden swell.
It gives the songs this cinematic quality without turning them into movie music.
They feel like scenes.
“Funeral” might be the song that convinced me this was something much bigger than a breakup album.
It’s about death. Depression. Grief.
The strange guilt of feeling bad about yourself when something genuinely terrible has happened to somebody else. I can relate. I think anyone can.
And somehow Phoebe writes it without making herself the centre of the universe. That’s incredibly difficult. There is a humility in her writing.
Even when she’s singing about herself, she understands that everyone else in the room has their own story. That’s probably why the songs travel so well.
You can put your own life inside them.
“Demi Moore” feels like a different kind of loneliness. Modern loneliness. The kind that exists when your phone is full of people but your room is empty. It’s intimate and sexual and sad and funny.
And again, she refuses to make loneliness glamorous. She makes it awkward. Which is much more honest.
That intimacy rarely happens in clean, cinematic scenes. It happens in messages. In voice notes. In stupid conversations. In the hours when neither person should still be awake. In the things you send and immediately regret. In the things you don’t send.
In the little digital archaeology we leave behind. Phoebe’s songs understand that world.
I can not skip mentioning the style and her image. For a first album of this caliber - she cracked the code. The skeleton suit. The blonde hair. The deadpan humour. The horror references. The oversized silhouettes. The slightly haunted California aesthetic. She made sadness look strangely cool without turning sadness into an aesthetic lifestyle. And that’s harder than it sounds.
There is a difference between looking sad and looking like someone who understands sadness. Even visually, she was creating a character who was both vulnerable and completely in control of the frame. That’s what I like about her. She doesn’t need to look powerful to be powerful.
I’ve shared this record because some albums are easier to give away than to explain. You can say: Listen to this.
And sometimes that is the entire conversation. I’ve sent songs because I couldn’t figure out how to say what I wanted to say.
I’ve had songs sent to me that I knew were carrying a message underneath them. Anyone who loves music knows this. We communicate through records.
Especially when we’re terrible at communicating directly. A song can say: I miss you. I remember you. I know what happened. I am angry. I want you. I don’t want you. I forgive you. I absolutely do not forgive you. Please leave me alone. Please don’t leave me alone.
All without anybody actually having to say it. That’s the secret language of music.
The thing I find most interesting about Stranger in the Alps now is how much bigger it feels than the story that initially surrounded it. Ryan Adams is part of its history. Sad but true. He wishes he was the center of it these days, I bet.
I recognise things in this album.
I recognise the way admiration can become complicated once you know the person, the way relationships can exist in the space between friendship, attraction, friendship again, something else, nothing, everything. I recognise the strange emotional geography of music scenes. And what it is to have a song attached to somebody who is no longer quite the person you thought they were.
That is why “Motion Sickness” hits me differently.
The artist makes the record. Then everyone else gets to ruin it with their own memories. We attach people to it.
Places. Sex. Heartbreak. Friendships.
Bad decisions. Good nights. People we should have stayed away from.
People we wish had stayed…And eventually, the record becomes ours.
Stranger in the Alps is mine in that way.
Not because I own it. Because I’ve lived alongside it. I’ve carried it through different versions of myself. And every time I come back to it, something has changed. Sometimes it’s the record.
Usually it’s me. That’s why I still put it on.
Because somewhere between the first notes of “Smoke Signals” and the final moments of “You Missed My Heart”, there is this strange little map of grief, sex, love, friendship, power, loneliness, humour, memory and becoming someone else.
A stranger in the Alps. A stranger in your phone. A stranger backstage. A stranger you once knew. A stranger who wrote a song you loved. A stranger who wasn’t a stranger at all.
And a record that somehow knows them all.
Comments