Jonesing For This One: Jack Frost's Accidental Magic
Two of Australia's finest songwriters, one unlikely collaboration and a chance encounter in a Sydney record shop. Matt Jones revisits Jack Frost's 1991 debut and the happy accident that brought it into his collection.
Sometimes the best records in your collection are the ones you never actually went looking for.
That's certainly the case with the 1991 debut album from Jack Frost, the wonderfully unlikely collaboration between Steve Kilbey of The Church and Grant McLennan of The Go-Betweens.
Two of Australia's great songwriters, both with very distinctive musical personalities, somehow meeting in the middle and creating something that sounds like both of them, but never quite like either.
And my introduction to it was completely by chance.
I wandered into a record store I wasn't expecting to visit and discovered there was an in-store appearance happening with Jack Frost and Steve Kilbey. One of those beautifully random moments that used to happen in record shops.
No algorithm, no notification, no carefully planned Record Store Day itinerary. You simply walked through a door and suddenly something interesting was happening.
Which is why my copy of Jack Frost is signed by Jack Frost and Steve Kilbey. This happened at Palings in Sydney, sometime around 1991.
Jack Frost occupies this wonderful space between Kilbey's dreamy, psychedelic poetry and McLennan's instinct for melodic, observational songwriting. At times, it feels like The Church have wandered into a Go-Betweens rehearsal; at others, like McLennan has stepped into one of Kilbey's strange, nocturnal landscapes.
But perhaps the most fascinating thing about Jack Frost is imagining what it could have been.
The story goes that the original Jack Frost concept was intended to stretch even further, potentially bringing Paul Kelly and Neil Finn into the fold. Unfortunately, getting four of Australasian music's busiest songwriters into the same place at the same time proved a logistical bridge too far.
Which is a shame because, seriously, imagine the music those four could have created. Or would there have been too many cooks in the kitchen?
There's a looseness to Jack Frost that's a huge part of its charm. It doesn't feel like two famous songwriters trying to manufacture a "supergroup". It feels like two talented friends discovering what happens when they throw songs, guitars, ideas and personalities into the same room.
And maybe that's why my own accidental discovery of it feels so appropriate.
I wasn't supposed to be in that record store.
I wasn't looking for Jack Frost.
I certainly wasn't expecting to meet them.
Yet somehow, I walked out with a signed copy of an album that has followed me around ever since.
In a world where the algorithm seems determined to predict the next song you'll love before you've even thought about it, there's something wonderfully romantic about that.
Wrong place. Right time. And Jack Frost was discovered.
Usually in these reviews, I analyse the best songs, but this time it's simply too hard. Every song deserves its place on Jack Frost, and choosing my favourites would be like choosing my favourite children.
Just put it on and lose yourself in two friends creating wonderful music together.
Most of my favourite records have been recommended to me by music-loving friends (you know who you are) or the team at my favourite record shop in Melbourne, Greville Records.
This time, though, it was pure chance that made Jack Frost a favourite.
The album is still out there on vinyl if you're prepared to hunt down a nice original pressing, and it was reissued in 2024. Seek out a copy and you'll be rewarded. Vinyl is the only way to listen to this one, too.
And perhaps next time you're passing a record shop, wander in without a plan. You never know what might be waiting inside.
Till next time, keep spinning.
Comments